Average New York mortgage costs at a glance
| Cost | New York | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Typical home value | $509,000 | Zillow, late 2025 |
| Effective property tax rate | 0.94% | Zillow, late 2025 |
| Average property tax bill | $4,793 a year | Zillow, late 2025 |
| Average homeowners insurance | $1,710 a year | NerdWallet 2026, $400,000 dwelling cover |
| 2026 conforming loan limit (most counties) | $832,750 | FHFA |
The calculator above starts with these New York averages. Replace them with the price, tax bill and insurance quote for the home you are looking at – costs vary a lot between counties and even neighborhoods.
Example: monthly payment on a typical New York home
For a $509,000 home with 20% down ($101,800), a $407,200 30-year fixed loan at an example rate of 6.25%:
- Principal and interest: $2,507.20
- Property tax (0.94%): $398.72
- Homeowners insurance: $142.50
- Total (PITI): $3,048.42 a month, before any HOA dues or PMI
With 20% down there is no PMI on a conventional loan. Put down less and the calculator adds PMI, or switch the loan type to FHA, VA or USDA.
New York property taxes
Property taxes vary enormously across New York. New York City's rates are relatively low as a share of market value, while many suburbs on Long Island, in Westchester and Rockland, and upstate cities such as Rochester and Syracuse have effective rates well above 2%. Most of the bill goes to the local school district. Eligible homeowners can receive the STAR credit or exemption for school taxes, and older homeowners with limited incomes may qualify for Enhanced STAR. Check the actual tax bill for the address and enter it in dollars.
Co-ops and condos in NYC: a co-op's monthly maintenance includes the building's property taxes and underlying mortgage, so enter it under HOA dues and set property tax to zero.
Homeowners insurance in New York
Homeowners insurance in New York is close to the national average overall, but coastal homes on Long Island and in parts of NYC pay more, and many need flood insurance. Condo owners need an HO-6 policy covering the interior and their liability; co-op owners need a similar policy.
Closing costs and transfer taxes in New York
New York has some of the highest closing costs in the US. Sellers pay the state transfer tax (0.4%, or 0.65% for NYC homes of $3 million or more) and, in NYC, the city transfer tax of 1%–1.425%. Buyers pay the mansion tax of 1% on homes of $1 million or more, and the mortgage recording tax – about 1.8%–1.925% of the loan in NYC and about 1.05% in many other counties (co-op loans are exempt). Attorneys handle most closings.
Affordable places to buy a home in New York
These New York cities rank among the most affordable for buyers in Redfin's analysis, which compares the typical mortgage payment with local incomes (not just the lowest prices). Prices are median sale prices for January–October 2025; the estimated payment uses 20% down, a 6.25% example rate, the state's average property tax rate and insurance.
| City | Median sale price | Est. monthly PITI | Where it is |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheektowaga | $239,216 | $1,508 | Buffalo suburb near the airport. |
| North Tonawanda | $242,646 | $1,528 | Along the Niagara River north of Buffalo. |
| Tonawanda (town) | $270,501 | $1,687 | Northern Buffalo suburb – No. 1 in New York for payment-to-income. |
| West Seneca | $295,040 | $1,827 | Southern Buffalo suburb. |
| Shirley | $526,686 | $3,149 | Suffolk County, Long Island's South Shore. |
| Central Islip | $584,903 | $3,482 | Central Suffolk County with Long Island Rail Road service. |
Lower prices can come with higher property tax rates or insurance costs, so always enter the actual figures for a specific home. Compare neighborhoods using official data such as school ratings from your state education department, crime statistics from local police and flood maps from FEMA.
New York loan limits for 2026
New York City and its surrounding counties have the high-cost 2026 limit of $1,249,125 for a one-unit home; most upstate counties use the $832,750 baseline.
First-time home buyer help in New York
The State of New York Mortgage Agency (SONYMA) offers low-interest first mortgages, Achieving the Dream for lower incomes, and a down payment assistance loan. New York City's HomeFirst program provides down payment assistance for qualified first-time buyers.
Most state programs require a homebuyer education course, have income and purchase-price limits, and must be used with an approved lender. Ask lenders whether they offer the state's program alongside FHA, VA, USDA and conventional loans.
Mortgage calculators for other states
California · Texas · Florida · Pennsylvania · Illinois · Ohio · Georgia · North Carolina · Arizona · US mortgage calculator
Averages are for planning only and change over time; they are not a quote or financial advice. Sources: Zillow property tax data (December 2025), NerdWallet homeowners insurance averages (2026), Redfin affordability data via Stacker (December 2025), FHFA and HUD 2026 loan limits.
Frequently asked questions
What is the average mortgage payment in New York?
On a typical New York home of about $509,000 with 20% down and a 30-year loan at 6.25%, principal, interest, property tax and insurance come to about $3,048 a month. Your payment depends on the price, rate, down payment and local taxes.
What is the property tax rate in New York?
The statewide effective rate is about 0.94% of home value, according to Zillow, but it varies by county, city and school district. Use the tax bill for the specific home when you can.
What is the mansion tax in New York?
A 1% tax paid by the buyer on residential purchases of $1 million or more anywhere in New York State. In NYC, higher rates apply from $2 million.
What is the mortgage recording tax in New York?
A tax on new mortgages, paid by the borrower: about 1.8% of the loan in NYC for loans under $500,000 and 1.925% above that, and about 1.05% in many other counties. Co-op loans are not subject to it.
How do co-op maintenance fees affect my mortgage payment?
Maintenance covers the building's property taxes, underlying mortgage, insurance and upkeep. Enter it as HOA dues in the calculator and set property tax to zero.