How the rent vs buy comparison works
A fair comparison does not just set the mortgage payment against the rent. It asks: after the same number of years, who has more money?
- If you buy, you pay the down payment and closing costs, then the mortgage, property tax, insurance, HOA dues and maintenance. When you sell, you keep the home's value minus the remaining loan and the selling costs.
- If you rent, you invest the down payment and closing costs instead, and pay rent and renters insurance. In any month when owning would cost more than renting, the renter invests the difference; when renting costs more, the buyer invests the difference.
The calculator runs this month by month and compares the two net worths at the end – and for every year from 1 to 30, so you can see the break-even year.
Why the time you stay matters most
Buying has large one-off costs – closing costs when you buy and selling costs (often 5%–8%) when you sell – and in the early years most of each mortgage payment is interest. Those costs are spread over more years the longer you stay, while rent usually keeps rising. That is why renting often wins for stays of a few years and buying often wins over longer periods, especially where rents are high relative to home prices.
Price-to-rent ratio
A quick rule of thumb is the price-to-rent ratio: home price ÷ annual rent for a similar home. A $400,000 home that would rent for $2,400 a month has a ratio of about 13.9. Ratios below about 15 tend to favour buying, and above about 20 tend to favour renting – but the full calculation above is far more reliable.
Assumptions to adjust
| Assumption | Default | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Home price growth | 3% a year | Higher growth favours buying; local markets vary widely. |
| Investment return | 5% a year | The return a renter earns on invested savings; higher returns favour renting. |
| Maintenance | 1% of value a year | Older homes often need more. |
| Rent increases | 3% a year | Fast-rising rents favour buying. |
The comparison ignores income tax effects such as the mortgage interest deduction, which most households no longer itemize under the higher standard deduction, and capital gains on investments. Estimate a buyer's full monthly cost with the mortgage calculator and your budget with the home affordability calculator.
For planning only, not financial advice. Future prices, rents and returns are uncertain.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to rent or buy a house?
It depends mainly on how long you will stay, local prices compared with rents, mortgage rates and what you could earn by investing instead. Buying usually wins over longer stays because the large buying and selling costs are spread over more years.
How many years do I need to stay for buying to be worth it?
Often around five to seven years, but it can be shorter in low-price, high-rent areas and much longer in expensive markets. The calculator shows your break-even year.
What is the price-to-rent ratio?
The home price divided by a year's rent for a similar home. Lower ratios (under about 15) tend to favour buying; higher ratios (over about 20) tend to favour renting.
Does the calculator include selling costs?
Yes. Buying is credited with the home's value minus the remaining mortgage and your selling costs, which you can change.